The European Space Agency on Reliability
August 30, 2016 | Barry Matties, I-Connect007Estimated reading time: 7 minutes
Stan Heltzel is a materials engineer working for the European Space Agency, and he is tasked with the job of procuring and qualifying PCBs that end up in satellites. I met with Stan at EIPC’s Summer Conference to discuss his presentation on qualifying a fabricator, his role at the ESA, and updating of space standards.
Barry Matties: Stan, please start by explaining a little about what you do.
Stan Heltzel: I’m a materials engineer at ESA and my responsibility is the qualification of printed circuit boards and the development of technology and qualifying the technology for space projects.
Matties: Everything you do is all about high reliability?
Heltzel: Yes.
Matties: You gave a presentation today on the qualification process, and talked a lot about the various approaches, the testing, and so on. What did you want the audience to take away from your presentation?
Heltzel: First of all, it’s the interaction between ESA, the national space agencies, contractors for satellite integration, and PCB manufacturers. They are working together in various organizational bodies and trying to address problems that no one organization could ever solve, so we’re doing that jointly. For instance, the nicest example I can think of is the cleanliness of the raw materials where PCB manufacturers were not in a position to ask for different quality standards from laminate suppliers until we got together as a group and addressed it all together.
Matties: Today you were showing some images of where you had peeled back the copper and found foreign debris in the mix. Is that something that’s commonly found, or is that an anomaly?
Heltzel: I think we should consider it an anomaly. We’re used to good quality materials that we get from laminate suppliers, but what we want is to be able to set the bar so we are able to distinguish between bad batches, if they oc casionally happen, and good ones. I don’t think it makes any sense to have inspection that does not discriminate between good clean materials and not-so-clean materials.
Matties: How do you even go about qualifying a fabricator to be a producer? What is it that you’re really looking for?
Heltzel: What’s important is that the qualified PCB manufacturer is committed to supply to the space industry for the long term. Then there are all kinds of technical requirements that are now written down in our standards, and for us to meet those technical requirements. Of course, some of these requirements are technically challenging to meet them 100% of the time. When we face problems, the really important thing is that we don’t give up. We should always have the mindset of continuous improvement and commitment to the space project to sort out any problems if they occur. I think that is one of the most important points to ESA.
Matties: Do you embed engineers from your agency into fabricator shops?
Heltzel: No, we do not.
Matties: You rely totally on their engineering and support to solve problems?
Heltzel: I audit PCB manufacturers. Also, the whole industry chain is involved with the quality assurance from PCB manufacturers, but inside those we do not have embedded engineers.
Matties: What is the greatest challenge in this whole process, from design to a completed board?
Heltzel: Mostly pricing, I’m afraid.
Matties: Really? I thought you had all the money you needed. It’s a government agency, right?
Heltzel: Let’s say the space project has a high budget, and it is an expensive business. But still, ESA does not buy the PCBs. It’s the industry buying the PCBs and the industry is pushing budget and they push back on PCB fabricators to provide a reliable PCB at a low cost. That is a conflict.
Matties: That sure is. The other aspect, of course, is that inspection is a standard step in almost every process for your application, I would imagine. That’s expensive, but necessary. A lot of people tell me, “If you have a process that’s in stable circumstances and you’re in control, you don’t need inspection.” It seems like that would be a mistake in this case.
Heltzel: It would be. We inspect a lot with regards to PCB procurement and PCB qualification. We are in the process of raising the bar in terms of the level of testing that we’re requiring and the number of inspections that we’re requiring. That work costs money but we justify that and we can quite easily convince industry that it’s just a fact that those inspections will then prevent failures later in the chain in manufacturing the product. Really, the expensive thing is when things go wrong and 20 people have to sit around the table once a week in a physical meeting to sort out the problems on schedule.
Matties: When things go wrong in the finished product, it’s hundreds of thousands of miles away perhaps, with no chance of repair.
Heltzel: When I speak about when things go wrong, it’s still ground-based.
Matties: That’s where you want to catch it.
Heltzel: You want to catch it before that. At the PCB level, you want to catch mistakes before they’re being assembled. It’s very late if we are catching things when we are performing ground-based environmental testing on the unit or even worse on the satellite. Keep in mind that these tests are also pretty severe tests of any electronic equipment that is passing, like a thermal vacuum campaign on the ground is expected to do well up in space.
Matties: Who’s doing your circuit design? Is that an internal function or is that farmed out?
Heltzel: That’s the industry’s responsibility— the OEMs.
Matties: So you basically go in and say, “We need something that gives us this functionality.”
Heltzel: Yes.
Page 1 of 2
Suggested Items
Trouble in Your Tank: Supporting IC Substrates and Advanced Packaging, Part 5
03/19/2024 | Michael Carano -- Column: Trouble in Your TankDirect metallization systems based on conductive graphite or carbon dispersion are quickly gaining acceptance worldwide. Indeed, the environmental and productivity gains one can achieve with these processes are outstanding. In today’s highly competitive and litigious environment, direct metallization reduces costs associated with compliance, waste treatment, and legal issues related to chemical exposure. What makes these processes leaders in the direct metallization space?
AT&S Shines with Purest Copper on World Recycling Day
03/18/2024 | AT&SThe Styrian microelectronics specialist AT&S is taking World Recycling Day as an opportunity to review the progress that has been made in recent months at its sites around the world in terms of the efficient use of resources:
Matrix to Exhibit at IPC APEX EXPO 2024 in Anaheim, CA
03/05/2024 | MatrixMatrix will be exhibiting at IPC APEX EXPO 2024, to be held on April 9-12, 2024, at the Anaheim Convention Center, Anaheim, CA.
The Chemical Connection: Getting to Know Your Vendor
02/16/2024 | Don Ball -- Column: The Chemical ConnectionAfter working for a capital equipment supplier for almost 50 years, I’ve found that the most important part of getting to know your vendor is good communication among all parties. While contact between fabricators of a constantly changing product line and the designers of those products may occur daily or weekly, conversations between you and your equipment supplier may be years apart. That lengthy gap often means that previous contacts may have been promoted, retired, or moved on to other opportunities. You may have also migrated to a new supplier with whom you have little or no history. In either case, you will be interacting with someone you are unfamiliar with (as they are with you). Therefore, it is essential for both sides to communicate clearly so expectations will align.
EIPC Winter Conference 2024, Day 2: A Closer Look at Global Trends
02/14/2024 | Pete Starkey, I-Connect007The opening session of the second day’s conference proceedings focused on global PCB trends and was introduced and moderated by Dr. Michele Stampanoni, vice president of strategic sales and business development at Cicor Group in Switzerland. He opened the session with Dr. Hayao Nakahara’s knowledgeable and enlightening video presentation on the IC substrates industry.