Innovative New Uses for Ceramic Column Grid Arrays from TopLine

Reading time ( words)

TopLine President and CEO Martin Hart sat down to discuss his paper on ceramic column grid arrays (CCGA) at the recent SMTA International show in Chicago. Hart begins by explaining the relationship between CCGA and ball grid arrays (BGA), and TopLine's drive to find new uses for CCGA.

Andy Shaughnessy: Martin, why don't you start by giving us a little background on CCGAs.

Martin Hart: The best way to talk about CCGAs is to reference their cousin, the BGA. Everybody is familiar with BGA—ball grid arrays. Few people realize that the CCGA, the ceramic column grid array, was actually invented about ten years before the first BGA. When BGA first came out, they were invented by Bell Laboratories; a full ten years after columns had already been in the field. The main purpose of having a column instead of a solder ball is to extend reliability. You get more temperature cycles out of a solder column because it will absorb the CTE mismatch between the materials of ceramic and substrate, such as an FR-4 PC board.

Shaughnessy: We just don't hear much about CCGA. Everybody seems to have settled on the BGA and flip chips and various other sorts of packaging. Why did the CCGA fall out of favor?

Hart: That's a good question. BGAs are lower cost and much easier to assemble. During the manufacturing process, attaching a solder ball is significantly easier than attaching a column. Solder balls roll and self-center onto the BGA pads. Columns are difficult to attach to the pads. They don't self-center because they are held rigidly in place, usually by a graphite tool, during the column attach process. Columns can easily get bend if handled incorrectly.

Shaughnessy: You have to literally stand this thing up.

Hart: You have to stand the column straight up during the attachment of the column to the substrate.

Shaughnessy: It sounds very risky, in a way.

Hart: There is an element of risk, but it’s more of a situation of having a correct manufacturing process. Your process has to be dialed to effectively use column grid arrays. Once you have a process in place, then CCGA seems to work well.

Shaughnessy: What is the new use that you seem to have found for them?

Hart: First I’ll tell you the traditional places where column grid arrays are used. Traditionally, they've been used in defense, military, aerospace and also in high-value computing. One new area is down-hole drilling, where you have electronics going down several miles. It's very hot as you go below the earth’s surface. There is also interest in specialized automotive where you have electronics in the firewall. Also, columns can be are found in some medical. Not medical implants in a human body, but in medical equipment. There is a benefit to use CCGA wherever you have a large ceramic package, and mounted on an FR-4 board or a polyimide board. CCGA is more reliable when the temperature swings dramatically.

If you have a very small ceramic, it's safe to use a BGA. I've researched and wrote some tables and calculations showing when it is safe to use a ceramic BGA and when you must use a CCGA. A small 15 mm square ceramic BGA will not cause any problem with solder ball delamination. But if you start to go larger, say a 35 mm square, 40 mm square, 45 mm or even larger, 50 mm square, then solder balls will delaminate. That will effectively create a catastrophic failure in the equipment.

I also want to point out that your equipment does not even have to be electrically switched on. Say, if your equipment is turned off, sitting in storage, then if you have a large ceramic part mounted with solder balls on an FR-4 board, then that equipment might fail. If your equipment is out in the elements experiencing alternating hot and cold temperatures, then your equipment might fail if it contains large ceramic BGA components. When the sun goes down, temperatures might drop -25 to -40°. And when the sun comes up temperatures might rise 100-125°. Just sitting in the box, you'll see the phenomenon of delamination with large ceramic BGA components.

Shaughnessy: What led you to focus more on CCGA?

Hart: The original business of TopLine was to manufacture process development kits of all kinds of parts, from BGA and QFP in a kit form with circuit boards. Customers, particularly in mil-defense, were asking for column grid arrays so they could perform their own process development. This has gone on for a number of years and we decided, "Okay, we need to jump in and address this market of producing CCGA and solder columns."

Shaughnessy: I guess CCGA would have its own completely different process.

Hart: Yes, it does. The process of attaching a column onto a ceramic substrate is totally different than attaching solder balls to a BGA. CCGA requires a graphite fixture to hold the column upright at a 90° angle. It involves having a controlled reflow process. We found that vapor phase reflow ovens are best solution because your maximum temperature is fixed.  You can also use a twelve-zone oven, but you have to have that oven profile really dialed to attach solder columns.

Shaughnessy: How tall is this column?

Hart: Oh, good question. Traditionally, columns are 2.2 mm high. There's nothing totally magical about 2.2 mm high. Columns have been made 1.27 mm, which is 50 mills. Columns have been made bigger in diameter and smaller in diameter. IBM set the standard years ago with studies and of papers showing that 2.2 mm, is a good column height. The industry settled ever since. The secret is actually in the attachment process. You start with a longer column and then trim it down to 2.2 mm during the planarization process. After all the columns are attached in an array, you literally have to cut the columns shorter to planarize them. So you wind up with 2.2 mm, but you start off with a column that is 2.3 mm, up to 2.5 mm, in order to wind up with 2.2mm.



Suggested Items

Tech 2 Tech: KYZEN’s Short Technical Sessions a Big Hit

01/20/2021 | Nolan Johnson, I-Connect007
Nolan Johnson gets an update from Tom Forsythe on KYZEN’s Tech 2 Tech sessions. These brief 15-minute sessions were set up during the pandemic by KYZEN for customers, prospects, and new engineers around cleaning, and have since found traction with their manufacturers, reps and distributors.

This Month in SMT007 Magazine—Continuous Improvement: As Simple as X = Xc – 1

01/04/2021 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
X=Xc – 1 is a conceptual equation for continuous improvement. You define X and work to reduce it by a factor of 1. This could be one work hour, one process step, one day less in a cycle, and so on. We recently met with Dr. Ron Lasky to discuss the concept of X=Xc – 1 and get his advice on generating enthusiasm among readers and the next generation about continuous improvement. As this discussion illustrates, many process improvements are small in scale, not yearlong, major efforts.

Top 10 Most-Read SMT Articles of 2020

12/31/2020 | I-Connect007
As 2020 comes to a close, the I-Connect007 Editorial Team takes a look back at its most read articles. Here are the top 10 reads in SMT from the past year.

Copyright © 2021 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.