Avoid Overbuilding your RF Printed Circuit Board


Reading time ( words)

Today, many companies are overbuilding and “overmaterializing” their RF printed circuit boards. In this interview, James Hofer of Accurate Circuit Engineering (ACE) shares some strategies to avoid doing both, which will help lower the total cost of your PCB and improve the overall product quality. Hofer also discusses some of the challenges in the laminate supply chain.

Barry Matties: Why don't you start by talking about Accurate Circuit Engineering; what do you do and what is your specialty?

James Hofer: Accurate Circuit Engineering is a high-tech prototype facility. We specialize in low volume, high mix. Our specialty is RF and signal integrity products. We do a lot of good cavities, and we handle all specialty materials; we especially use a lot of Rogers, Taconic, and Arlon, which is now also Rogers. We stock R4000 series, because 4000 series is an advanced dielectric for signal integrity. We probably run somewhere between 15 and 30 jobs a week on R4000, which we stock because Rogers just recently was quoted as, "We're very proud to say our lead-time on the 4000 series is now only 35 days." That's more than a month.

We specialize in quick-turn. I can run 16-layer, high-frequency jobs with impedance on multiple layers in 24 hours. We can also go up to 20 days. We do everything from the AT test boards to gigantic antennas. Everybody who has a wave-guide analyzer or an amplifier is using boards for those, and our boards are just the kind of things to go in there.

Matties: Yes, RF is a booming area right now.

Hofer: RF satellite is back up and on top of everybody's minds right now, with all the advanced unmanned vehicles that everybody from civilian to military is using. All of that is RF. We're going faster and faster, higher and higher. All our smartphones are using RF-type and wireless technology. All of that requires test equipment, design equipment, prove-out equipment, and every one of those has a circuit board.

Matties: Your manufacturing focus is RF. How long have you had that focus?

Hofer: I brought that focus on board with Accurate about 12 years ago. I've been with Accurate 15 years now, and when I started we were just doing rigid boards, whatever came our way, and I wanted Accurate to move forward and have a specialty. When somebody says, “Who does RF boards? Oh, Accurate does RF boards,” we are right there. That has really worked out for us, because not only are we seeing a lot of activity in that area, but we were also very good at it. It has really propelled us to the next level.

Matties: We've done a few surveys recently—you may have seen—about supply chain and also the war on failure. In the RF arena, failure is just not even an option when you're dealing with military satellites, commercial aircraft, that sort of thing. How do you battle failure in your process?

Hofer: We start from the minute we get the customer design. We run it through DFM and DRC checks. We verify their calculations. We take a look at how their structure is and how their stack-up is and how they've laid everything out, to make sure that it's going to be robust enough in the finished product to withstand multiple heat cycles, vibration, etc.

Then during our own manufacturing process, because we're also MIL-certified and AS9100 certified, we have process checks and process documentation to ensure that when we're manufacturing the board, it's seeing only processes that have been vetted and are monitored in performance, tracked, and managed. Once the finished product is done, we put it through construction integrity testing, full electrical testing, and then full dimensional and measurement testing before we ship it out to the customer.

Matties: Interestingly, I've looked at this in the supply chain from fabricator to assembler, and it seems to me that no matter how stable your processes are, you could be using best practices and all that but inspections are the only line of defense.

Hofer: Nothing is 100%. Even computers are 99.9999%, and that's not a hundred. Inspection is really the key to prevent escapes, because you're right, in manufacturing, in life, mistakes are going to happen and people are going to make mistakes and mistakes make people. It's how you move forward from them that's important. The inspection steps—which is why we have so many inspection steps along the way of manufacturing and at final—are the only way you keep it from getting out to assembly and then getting out into a product. Even that, unfortunately, is not at 100%. Sometimes things escape. We see it on the news all the time.

Matties: Absolutely. Airbags, ignition switches, falling satellites, or whatever it happens to be.

Hofer: That's correct.

Matties: It's really interesting, and you mentioned materials. The other part we looked at was supply chain and how difficult it is to get materials. What sort of demands or impacts has that had on your business?

Share

Print


Suggested Items

I-Connect007 Editor’s Choice: Five Must-Reads for the Week

08/28/2020 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
This week, we have quite a potpourri for you. There's good news about the PCB market. And as this year continues to surprise us at every turn, companies are discovering the true nature of their leaders. Todd Kolmodin has a great column about bosses and leaders and why the two words are not synonymous. Not to be outdone, columnist Barry Olney found a way to explain the wavelength of electromagnetic energy by using a chocolate bar and a microwave oven. We also have great articles by Sagi Reuven and Pete Starkey.

Book Excerpt: Producing the Perfect Data Package

06/03/2020 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
The following is an excerpt from Chapter 1 of Mark Thompson's I-Connect007 eBook "The Printed Circuit Designer’s Guide to... Producing the Perfect Data Package." Mark is in engineering support at Prototron Circuits and a Design007 columnist.

The Cost of Inefficient Production of PCB Documentation

05/13/2020 | Mark Gallant, DownStream Technologies
The following article is an excerpt from Chapter 5 of the I-Connect007 eBook The Printed Circuit Designer’s Guide to… Documentation, written by Mark Gallant of DownStream Technologies.



Copyright © 2020 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.