Mr. Laminate Tells All: Where in the Holy Halogens did 900, 900, 1500 Come From?
November 12, 2015 | Doug Sober, Essex Technologies GroupEstimated reading time: 4 minutes
I took the requirements from IEC-61249-2-21 and imported them into the IPC standards development process, creating document IPC-4101/92. The test method for the determination of halogen content in base materials, IEC 61189-2C12, was imported into the IPC manual simply by rewriting it in IPC format. IPC-TM-650 Method 2.4.41 was the test method number used by the IPC to determine the halogen content of FR-4 CCL. Underwriters’ Laboratories (UL) uses this test today to define which products are ANSI grade FR-4.0 and which are ANSI grade FR-4.1.
From that time, other IEC and IPC documents have been developed for epoxy, polyimide and cyanate ester halogen-free CCL grades and prepregs. The requirement has also always remained as 900, 900, and 1500, as previously discussed. Only one test method has been referenced.
Neither TC91/WG4 nor IPC planned to use this requirement for any other products other than CCL in the electronics supply chain. The specification was developed for and was only applicable to FR-4 CCL and prepreg. However, some years later, several OEM computer manufacturers and others decided that the 900, 900, 1500 requirements could be applied to everything else in the electronics supply chain, including soldermask, legend ink, adhesives, cases and power cords. PVC, used in many electronics applications, was now also to be eliminated as it contained chlorine.
This expansion to other materials was supposed to be documented in a new standard, IPC/JEDEC Joint Standard 709, but there was controversy as to why a CCL specification had relevance to soldermask or adhesive or anything else for that matter. There was also a belief that chlorine and bromine should only be reported if it came from organic chlorine and bromine found in flame retardants. Additionally, there was also discontent as to why fluorine was not considered a halogen for definition purposes. I still wonder that, too. However, after several years of meetings, comments and balloting, this document was never published by IPC, but JEDEC did decide to publish by itself and under their own logo.
I have seen many announcements in trade journals indicating that some new material in the electronics supply chain has been developed and is halogen-free based on the 900, 900, 1500 requirements. Of course these requirements are not related to any historical testing on the materials referenced. The requirements are not being pulled from thin air but more like rarified air.
I apologize on behalf of myself and Dr. Shibata for creating this requirement that has been exported into so many areas unrelated to CCL.
Doug Sober is the president of Essex Technologies Group and may be reached by clicking here.
Page 2 of 2Suggested Items
I-Connect007 Editor’s Choice: Five Must-Reads for the Week
05/03/2024 | Nolan Johnson, I-Connect007This week’s most important news is strategic—and telling. When one puts together the IPC industry reports, we simply have to include the recent conversation with Shawn DuBravac and Tom Kastner. On the design side, check out the latest “On The Line With…” podcast featuring Brad Griffin from Cadence Design Systems, discussing SI and PI in the realm of intelligent system design.
IMI Welcomes New CEO
05/03/2024 | IMIIntegrated Micro-Electronics, Inc. (IMI),The IMI Board of Directors announced, in a disclosure dated April 25, 2024, the appointment of Louis Sylvester Hughes, Chief Executive Officer (CEO).
Electronics Industry Sentiment Rose in April, Hitting New High
05/02/2024 | IPCApril 2024 marked the third consecutive month of sentiment growth among electronics manufacturers. When asked if they expected labor costs for hourly workers to rise over the next month, manufacturers in the United States, Mexico, and Europe predicted a five percent increase, while manufacturers in Asia predicted a slightly lower four percent increase.
iNEMI Names Grace O'Malley CTO
05/02/2024 | iNEMIThe Board of Directors of the International Electronics Manufacturing Initiative (iNEMI) has named Grace O'Malley Chief Technical Officer (CTO).
ZESTRON Academy Launches 2024 Advanced Packaging & Power Electronics Webinar Series
05/01/2024 | ZESTRONZESTRON, the leading global provider of high-precision cleaning products, services, and training solutions in the electronics manufacturing and semiconductor industries, proudly announces the launch of its highly anticipated webinar series on Advanced Packaging & Power Electronics, a webinar series on the latest innovations, cleaning, and corrosion challenges.